Elk Wellington - Our Favorite Venison Recipes

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you make a purchase using these links. As an Amazon Associate, and a King Arthur Baking affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Share this Recipe!

My family likes to hunt deer and elk in the fall, whether in Kansas or Colorado. In fact, we practically lived on venison meat for the first 15 years of our marriage. During that time, I learned how to best prepare the ground burger, steaks, and roasts. Some of the recipes were okay. Some were amazing. For anyone out there who has wild game in their freezer, I thought it might be good to share Our Favorite Venison Recipes with you!

Game Meat - Deer - Elk

(Post modified with new photos on 1/1/23.)

For many years, my husband and I did all the processing of the meat ourselves, grinding the burger, cutting up the steaks, roasts, and backstraps, and packaging it for the freezer. Now, with the addition of our sons-in-law, which equates into a lot more deer meat, we’ve opted to keep the backstraps and haul everything else to the butcher. This seems to work well, plus we have the option of ordering summer sausage and jerky sticks!

 

What Does Wild Game Taste Like?

Wild game cooks much like beef, except it is leaner, denser, darker, and possibly more tough. Sometimes it is gamey, depending on the deer. So for those of you out there who have never tasted deer, gaminess might be described as a strong, earthy flavor and smell. It comes from having lived and grazed in the wild. What the animal eats and the amount of fat involved. Yes, many deer in SE Kansas eat corn and grain, but they don’t live on it.

Gaminess also has to do with how old the animal is. The older the deer, the more gamey it will be. And hormones. If you’re hunting a bull or buck near its rutting season, it’s going to taste gamey. That said, we’ve had deer and elk meat (usually a doe or cow) that tasted nearly as good as beef, so it just depends.

 

How to Remove Gamey Taste in Meat

So, how do you reduce the gamey taste and smell of the meat? There are a few ways, but they all involve soaking or marinating.  You could soak the meat in milk overnight in the refrigerator, soak it in a saltwater brine, or soak it in beer or wine, which is the way I prefer to deal with it. This also has the added benefit of tenderizing the meat, which is also good.

Now that we’ve covered a lot of the bases, let’s move on to our favorite recipes–ten of them!

 

Ten of Our Favorite Venison Recipes

Ground Venison Burger

 

#1 – After much trial and error in cooking with venison, I learned the best recipes for using the roasts, steaks, and burger. This Thick Venison Chili recipe is one that uses ground venison burger.

We have found when processing ground venison that it tastes better if you add a little beef tallow (or lard) to the meat to give it more flavor as well as add some fat to the very lean meat. We suggest between 15-20% of tallow works well, to give it 85/15 or 80/20 ratio.

1
Featured Image - Thick Venison Chili
Thick Venison Chili
The first ten years of our marriage, we nearly lived on wild game, much of it deer or elk meat. Here's a chili recipe using ground venison that is thick, which my husband likes.
Check out this recipe

 

#2- Whether I’m cooking with ground venison or beef, this recipe for Venison Burgers with Fry Sauce is a winner. It’s easy to make and adding the homemade fry sauce takes it to the next level that will make your family smile with satisfaction.

2
Recipe for Venison Burgers with Fry Sauce
Venison Burgers with Fry Sauce
Here is a delicious recipe to make in a skillet or on the grill. Ground venison works especially well, but ground beef is good too.
Check out this recipe

 

#3  – Potluck Barbecued Meatballs are a great way to use ground venison, as the recipes call for a lean meat. Plus, the following recipe is baked in a sauce, which helps tenderize the meat, and I like the added flavor that the venison gives the meatballs.

3
Featured Image - Potluck Barbecued Meatballs
Potluck Barbecued Meatballs
Make Potluck Barbecued Meatballs for your next church dinner or holiday party. Tender, juicy meatballs cooked in a homemade barbecue sauce. Perfect as a main dish or as an appetizer. I've been making these meatballs for many years and it always goes over well.
Check out this recipe

 

#4 – Our family loves John Wayne movies, so when I discovered this dish, adapted from an actual recipe that John Wayne submitted for a cookbook, I had to try it. This John Wayne Venison Casserole is perfect for your next potluck dinner. It always goes over very well.

4
Featured Image - John Wayne Venison Casserole
John Wayne Venison Casserole
Our family loves John Wayne movies, so when I discovered this dish, adapted from an actual recipe that John Wayne submitted for a cookbook, I had to try it. This John Wayne Venison Casserole is perfect for your next potluck dinner. It always goes over very well.
Check out this recipe

 

#5 and #6 – Mexican Food is also another great choice for using the ground venison or steaks in your freezer. The added spices work really well with the flavor of the meat. And I like that it is lean and not fatty. My three top choices for Mexican food is Beef Fajitas, and Ground Beef Taco Meat. Here again, I will often combine 1/2 venison with 1/2 ground beef to help balance the flavor.

5
Recipe for Beef and Chicken Fajitas
Beef and Chicken Fajitas
We love Mexican food, and I probably make it at least twice a month. It's a great meal to plan when our entire family has gathered at our house as the options are many and the ingredients go a long way to serve many people. Beef and Chicken Fajitas is one of those favorite recipes that everyone enjoys!
Check out this recipe

 

6
Recipe for Ground Beef Taco Meat
Ground Beef Taco Meat
I use this Ground Beef Taco Meat for many Mexican-style dishes at our house. It’s easy to put together and so tasty, whether you’re  using it to make tacos, enchiladas, Montereys, chimichangas, taco burgers, or flautas. So versatile!
Check out this recipe

 

Venison Steak, Stew Meat, or Roasts

#7 – Our granddaughter adores this stew. We’ve nicknamed it “Mountain Stew” because we always make Chunky Venison Stew when we go camping in the mountains. It is one of our favorite stews, and I love to serve my Country Biscuits or Savory Southwest Biscuits with it.

7
Featured Image - Recipe for Chunky Venison Stew
Chunky Venison Stew
My husband and daughters like to hunt deer and elk in the fall. This is a great venison recipe full of hearty meat and chunks of potato, carrots, and peas.
Check out this recipe

 

#8 – German Venison Rouladen is fabulously flavorful and possibly my new favorite German food. If you’re not familiar with this recipe, think thin slices of venison rolled up around bacon, onion, and cornichons (German pickles), then slow-cooked in wine until they are fall-apart-fork-tender. Delicious!

8
Featured Image - Recipe for German Venison Rouladen
German Venison Rouladen
This dish is fabulously flavorful and possibly my new favorite German food. If you’re not familiar with Rouladen, think thin slices of venison rolled up around bacon, onion, and cornichons (German pickles), then slow-cooked in wine until they are fork-tender. Delicious!
Check out this recipe

 

#9 – I would be remiss if I didn’t include Venison Jerky in this list of favorites. We’ve been making this recipe for many years now to give as gifts, and also to use for snacks, or for taking on vacations. This recipe for Venison Jerky easily compares to what you might buy at specialty shops. It’s very well seasoned and not hard to make.

9
Recipe for Venison Jerky
Venison Jerky
This is a recipe that easily compares to what you buy at specialty shops. Very good and not hard to make.
Check out this recipe

 

#10 – Last, and certainly not least, is my recipe for Elk Wellington with Madeira Sauce that I made last year with one of my son-in-laws. Start with a pan-seared elk tenderloin fillet, brushed with Dijon mustard, cloaked in mushroom Duxelles and prosciutto, and then wrapped in a homemade sourdough puff pastry that has been baked to golden perfection. Finish off by topping it with a generous spoonful of silky Madeira sauce that has simmered in a demi-glace sauce of vegetables and herbs. This recipe may also be used to make two smaller Venison (deer) Wellingtons.

10
Recipe for Elk Wellington with Madeira Sauce - Featured Image
Elk Wellington with Madeira Sauce
Want to wow your dinner party guests with a meal fit for a king? This Elk Wellington with Madeira Sauce is the perfect choice. 
Check out this recipe

 

I hope this list of venison recipes will serve you well. If you have a favorite way to cook venison, I’d love for you to share with me in the comments below! See more Venison and Wild Game Recipes Here. Browse more Entertaining Ideas Here.

 

Share this Recipe!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 Comments

  1. You offer so many great venison recipes and love the tips about the gaminess and the different ways to soak the meat.

    1. Thanks for stopping by. If you have a chance to try one of these venison recipes, I hope you’ll enjoy it!

    1. I have not tried it with my Ragu Bolognese recipe but I bet it would work well. I hope you enjoy the chili and burgers!